Stop Your Dog’s Whining

  • Pin It

  • Pin It

Stop Your Dog’s Whining

why is my dog whining

 

I hate, absolutely HATE dog whining!

But, unfortunately I think a large majority of people are actually teaching their dogs to whine.

Let’s Start with Barking

I think we can both agree that dog barking is a problem, too!

And, I have written many an article on why dogs bark and how to keep them from barking and why correcting your dog for barking isn’t working.

So hopefully, people are not rewarding their dogs for barking.

If he barks at you to throw the ball; don’t throw it.

If he barks at you to feed him; don’t feed him.

If he barks to come out of his crate; don’t let him out.

Your dog must learn that barking is not rewarding. And for a great video series that shows you how to stop barking click here.

One little mistake of inadvertently rewarding this behavior (throwing his ball, feeding him, giving him what he wants) can then make it so much more difficult to eradicate!  Because dogs like barking; so if an hour of straight barking is what it takes once, then prepare for double that the following time!

Whining is the Same

Whining is actually virtually the same as barking except that many humans are more likely to give in to a whining puppy or dog.

There are a couple of reasons.

People Feel Sorry For and Coddle a Puppy that Whines

dog whining

People often feel sorry for a puppy or a dog that whines.

Barking is irritating, at best.

That is equated as the sound of an angry dog.

But for some reason whining brings about a more maternal instinct in many humans; male and female.

“He sounds so sad, I had to let him out!”

However this just teaches the dog to whine when he wants something.

I guess it works for some kids too!

I am not a fan of whining for either species.

I mean, what are we rewarding?

I remember when one of my best friend’s children went through this phase (which had clearly been rewarded at some point, since it existed and continued for a few weeks); I used to say “I can’t hear you when you whine, and since she was like 4, she believed me and stopped whining to me.

If I say “no” I mean NO whether you are human or K9.

And, if you want something, there are other ways to ask… even if you are a dog!

When my dogs want a treat, they get eye contact and then very slowly, all while maintaining eye contact take my eyes to where the cookie jar is and then stare.

That is much better than barking, or whining in my opinion and I can easily walk away or ignore it if I so choose.

ic-for-whining

A Means of Misguided Communication

The other is a means of misguided communication.

When a puppy first wakes up at night and rustles in his crate, then he whines; and often he is let outside.

Or he whines if he is tethered.

We all want a dog that is potty trained!

But I don’t want to inadvertently teach my puppy that whining is the means of communication that I need in order for him to receive what he wants!

This means he that he will whine when he wants everything.

And, it also means that he will whine aggressively when he is ignored.

And, aggressive whining is soooooo much worse (IMO) than aggressive barking.

I can correct and control barking; but this is nearly impossible with whining.

And if I want to utilize a citronella collar, to help my dog learn not to bark while I am away, whining won’t trigger it.

Again, I prefer that my dog never learn that it is effective or a means of communication at all!

I ignore puppy whining like it doesn’t exist at all.

I reward quiet.

Sometimes I capture and/or correct barking.

I NEVER do either with whining.

Even trying to “correct” it brings attention and acknowledgement that it exists.

So What Do You Do To Stop Your Dog’s Whining?

dog is whiningI know that is your question, right?

What if your puppy whines in his crate at 3 o’clock and you know he has to go outside?

You either missed the first signal (getting up and being restless) or you wait until the whining subsides for a moment or two.

I personally put my crate right by my side of the bed and I listen for a puppy that gets up or walks around in his kennel; then I immediately get him outside BEFORE he whines or barks!

It is my job to reward the behaviors I prefer.

If I take my pup out for whining or barking, I am telling or miscommunicating (in many instances) that this is what I want my puppy to do when he wants something.

Instead, it is up to me to wait and find a behavior I would like to reward.

OR, for those of you who sleep soundly, set an alarm and take your pup out every few hours.

Yes, that is inconvenient, but so is teaching your puppy to whine and ruin your sleep, your car rides, and your sanity!

We must realize that it is those short moments of weakness that we “give in” where our puppies unfortunately learn the most about us and then they use it OFTEN to get what they want!

If, however, we think through our choices before we act, we can choose to only reward those behaviors (using proper puppy training techniques) we want to continue to see in the future!

Want To Stop Your Dog’s Whining?

Access my step-by-step collection of tutorial videos specifically guiding you through how to teach your dog to stop whining and other annoying behaviors, and control it’s impulses.

Click here to enroll in the Impulse Control Class

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

There are 2 Comments

  1. Julie Frank says:

    I am not very computer literate. I can barely get my email so there’s no chance of me signing up for an online class. I am a fellow dog trainer and I also have a service dog of my own. I have corrected this problem in many many dogs mine and my clients. However my current service dog whines in the car.
    This is her only negative behavior and I have not been able to correct it. If I use a shock collar it slows it down a lot but does not completely eradicate the behavior. I really could use your suggestions. Other trainers have told me to teach the bark and the quiet but she already knows all of those and never barks when I tell her not to. She is a very good dog and well-trained but this one problem is still an issue. Thank you for your input,
    sincerely Julie

    [Reply]

  2. Joyce Billings says:

    Looks like most of your training is aimed to puppies. We adopted an older dog who is a whiner…. from you comments it looks like there is nothing we can do to stop the whining in older dogs. He also barks when we go for a ride in our ATV. For the first couple of months he would ride quietly … now it is not fun to ride the ATV with him as he barks at ear busting volume. If I ride we put him in the house so I can enjoy riding through the property. Other wise he is a good dog and has a great recall command response…good for when he wanders out of sight.

    [Reply]

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *