Consistency, the Critical Ingredient to Any Dog Training

Depositphotos_31185263_xsConsistency, we don’t usually have it.

Humans are odd mammals… we have consistency when it comes to all the wrong things, and we lack consistency when we need it.

Yes, yes

Yes, most of us have a fairly consistent routine.

We probably get up at about the same time, go to work at the same time or same days, eat dinner approximately the same time, and go about our daily mundane duties about the same.

But most of us are not consistent with our dogs and their behaviors.

We get a puppy.

We are all excited to bring it home and train it right.

It comes home, shows all kinds of natural doggy behaviors (like jumping, barking, having accidents in the house) that people consider bad and then the puppy either gets ignored, banned (like putting them outside all day) or occasionally beaten.

People rarely see a problem and ask themselves what THEY are doing to promote or continue that problem.

People often expect a dog to be born with the same ideals that they have; all dogs should know not potty outdoors right?  All dogs should know not to jump on us right?

And, we seldom attempt to fix a “problem” (especially a problem with another living thing) in the same way.

  • We get frustrated.
  • We blame.
  • Sometimes there are consequences, sometimes there are not.
  • Sometimes we actually reward bad behavior just because we want the dog to stop the immediate behavior.

Ever thrown a ball for a dog who was barking at you to throw his ball?

Ever fed your dog because he is driving you crazy?

The dog (and sometimes the child) never knows when they will reach the breaking point.  Will you give in?  Or will you lose your cool and punish?

Dogs are eternal optimists.

They always think you are going to give in, if it is at all a possibility.

You could upper cut him to the jaw 9 out of 10 times and he is still holding out hope that this time he will either get away with it, or be rewarded.

This is one of the joys of living with a dog, and one of the things that is hard for most people to grasp.

You can correct the dog 90% of the time but if you reward him just once or he finds a way to reward himself, then that is what he is likely to remember and work toward.

That means you have to work even more diligently to be consistent in order to make a difference when you have let a bad behavior slide.

Let’s Look at it From the Dog’s View

warrior dog and sword

warrior dog and sword

He has jumped on you over 1,000 times, when you come home from work, when you are going to work, when you are outside playing, when you are inside picking up his toys, when you are laying on the ground, when you are laying on the sofa.

He is like a ninja jumper.

So you have a bad day at work.  The boss yells at you for something you were never taught how to do, you had a bad hair day (ladies), you’re tired from not sleeping, the kids got in trouble at school.

You get home, the ninja strikes from what seems like out of nowhere and you lose your cool completely.

Yelling, lashing out, trying to catch him, trying to knee him or worse.

All while he is running around trying to figure out if you are kidding.  Let’s admit it, you could be furious, livid, and spewing hate and he is bouncing and bounding all over the house just hoping you can’t catch him.

If you think about it, can you blame him?

Remember he has done it thousands of times successfully.

He doesn’t know you had a bad day.  Heck dogs don’t really understand bad days, they are happy all of the time!

How to Change

If your dog has a behavior problem that bothers you (what one person hates another could love) then you must be consistent with your reaction and make a change.

You can’t think the behavior is cute sometimes.

Or tolerable sometimes.

Or even bad all of the time but lack any kind of training and follow through.

Because often dog owners are shouting NO! NO! Bad Dog!  But the dog hears it so often it has no reaction.

Aim for 100% consistency.

That means if he barks at 1 am in the morning, and you don’t want barking there are repercussions, even if you have to drag your tired rump out of bed to do it.

If you don’t want jumping, teach your dog an incompatible behavior (like sitting or lying down) and reward those behaviors and if your dog jumps on you in a greeting; make sure that you deny him access to you for a while.

If every time my dog jumps on me, he goes outside or in another room without me; he learns that jumping = something that is the opposite of what he wants.  He jumps on you because he wants to be close to you and with you right?

Now, if you skip the step of actually teaching him “four on the floor” or any other incompatible behavior you are likely to still suffer from some jumping.

If however he finds a way that he feels he can reward himself with your affection (sitting or lying down or showing any other good behavior) then he will be able to choose these instead of jumping!

But you must be consistent, or he’ll be hoping for those times you don’t make him do anything and he can still jump.

They are always waiting for us to give in and for them to get their way.

They are just like kids.

I can’t tell you how often I have heard my husband say “If you ask to go to McDonalds one more time we aren’t going”.

The problem is that he is never consistent, so they beg, and they beg, and they beg until I about turn purple and then…. Sure enough he gives in and they get what they want.

Which essentially teaches them to beg for something mercilessly until they get it.

And, dogs are kids are great optimists!

If however, immediate after he gives a warning and one of the kids breaks it, he makes a point to prove that there is no way we are going… then the kids would learn to pipe down after the first warning.

Instead, they are trying for 50 tries at begging for the one chance that 52 will bring them a burger and the happy meal toy.

Where it would be so much easier to say NO or to tell them yes and then give them a time frame.  Plus it would make the next encounter a million times easier.

I would rather say NO and mean it.

Actually, I am too much of an animal trainer, if I say NO I mean NO and there is really nothing you can do to change my mind.

Otherwise I feel like it is the above scenario and I am not being fair.

After all the kids would rather me go back on my word and they would get what they want but again, that is not fair nor is it sticking to my word.

Be Fair

So be fair!

Stick to your word.

Do things the same way that you always would.

If you have to punish or take a privilege, do it immediately so that the dog understands.

But do it kindly and make sure it doesn’t last long.

Dogs have short attention spans.  Ignoring them for 3 hours because you are mad isn’t fair to them.

Giving them a separation of 5 minutes probably feels like 3 hours to them.

And, remind everyone in the home that the kind way to train is by using consistency and not breaking rules!

Start Calming Down Your Over Excited Dogs Today!

Your First Lesson’s FREE:

Sign up below and we’ll email you your first “Training For Calm” lesson to your inbox in the next 5 minutes.


  1. Paul Clark Jr says:

    Thank you for sharing this information it very important for Bell and I she’s 4 mo old German Shepherd black and tan because I want the best for her I want the best for her because she’s a very smart and deserve it once again thanks for your input well needed stay in touch Paul Clark Jr


  2. Diana Hauser says:

    100% agree and something we tell all of our clients with every lesson!


  3. Sara says:

    You say you’re an animal trainer, which I’m assuming means you love animals… Yet you’re talking about going to McDonald’s?! Eating animals is violence, it is animal cruelty. If you wouldn’t eat golden retriever meat, why is it ok to eat cow meat?


    Minette Reply:

    Very different, but I am not going to argue this 😀


  4. Peggy says:

    I totally agree with the article. I have been consistent on big dogs off the furniture. Everytime he even puts his paws on the sofa, he is corrected. But when he wants attention from my husband he climbs on the sofa, and gets petted by my husband….and scolded from me. He thinks it is ok to do it because he is praised and petty by my husband and it drive me nuts…….everyone has to be consistent, not just one person. 🙁


    Minette Reply:

    That is what consistency is all about


  5. could you help to train my small dog poodle mix, to stop her from licking on everything, i try to keep her treats to chew on ,that seeme to work for a while? please help, i just got married & he does’nt like this..


  6. Florence says:

    I have two very territorial female yorkie mixes, almost five. On walks when they see other dogs they go off the hook. At home when the door bell rings crazy barking, also when they hear voices or when someone comes in. I can’t even talk to anyone without them flipping out. It’s extremely frustrating, discouraging and above all embarrassing. I’ve almost been at the point of giving them up on several occasions because of it. Together both dogs are difficult to deal with, they feed off each other. 🙁


    Minette Reply:

    You;ll probably have to work with them separately, then teach them to bark and be quiet on command. for help with that search those topics in the search bar at the top.

    I also think the dogs need more basic obedience and also more exercise.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *